XPost: alt.christnet.christnews, alt.bible
From: usenet@christrose.news
========================================
Wed, 28 Jan 2026 13:07:59 -0500
<765knkhaeodljh4hf63qjgfu5onflri95r@4ax.com>
Watchtower Heretic James wrote:
========================================
>> After the thousand year reign of Christ (Revelation 19-20:10), The
>> present heavens and earth will flee away, and be replaced by a new
>> heavens and earth for believers (Revelation 21).
> Yes, it will be a cleansed earth (people), and a cleansed ruling
> class. (heavens)
>
> I know you like everything to be literal, but new heavens and earth
> means a change of government. The ruling class will be Jesus and the
> 144,000.
>
> What does a landlord do when he rents out an apartment and the people
> ransacked it? Burn down the apartment? No, he fixes it, then rents it
> to better people. In a similar way, that what happens to the heavens
> and the earth.
You are again replacing what the text says with what your system needs
it to say.
First, you assert “cleansed people” and a “cleansed ruling class,” but
Revelation never defines “heavens” as a ruling class in this context.
That definition is imported. Revelation itself defines its symbols when
it uses them. Here, it does not.
John describes *events*, not political reform.
“From his presence earth and sky fled away, and no place was found for
them” (Revelation 20:11, ESV).
That is not cleansing. That is removal. Something cleansed does not flee
out of existence. Something judged does.
Then John says:
“Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the
first earth had passed away” (Revelation 21:1, ESV).
You keep saying “cleansed,” but John says “passed away.” Those are not
the same thing. Scripture knows how to speak of cleansing. It does not
do so here.
Second, your landlord analogy fails because God Himself rejects it.
Hebrews applies Psalm 102 directly to the Son:
“They will perish, but you remain… like a garment they will be changed”
(Hebrews 1:11–12, ESV).
A landlord does not roll up an apartment like a robe. God says He will
roll up the heavens and earth. That is not refurbishment language. That
is replacement language.
Third, Peter explicitly denies your “repair only” model.
“The heavens will pass away with a roar, and the heavenly bodies will be
burned up and dissolved” (2 Peter 3:10, ESV).
Dissolved is not cleaned. Melted elements are not refurbished. You are
trying to downgrade Peter’s language to fit an analogy he never uses.
Peter then says:
“But according to his promise we are waiting for new heavens and a new
earth” (2 Peter 3:13, ESV).
Again, if this were merely a repaired system, “new” is misleading at
best. Peter is not careless with words.
Fourth, your claim about government collapses under Revelation itself.
Revelation already describes Christ’s reign and the saints reigning with
Him during the thousand years (Revelation 20:4–6). If “new heavens and
earth” simply means a new government, then Revelation 21 adds nothing
new. But John clearly presents Revelation 21 as *after* the final
judgment, not as a restatement of millennial rule.
Chronology matters.
– Millennium: Christ reigns on the present earth
– Final judgment: earth and sky flee
– New creation: new heaven and new earth appear
You are collapsing stages Scripture keeps distinct.
Fifth, the 144,000 do not function as a ruling “heavens” class in
Revelation 21.
Revelation 21 never mentions the 144,000 at all. It speaks of:
– God dwelling with man
– Death no more
– Creation fully renewed
If the ruling class were the meaning of “new heavens,” this would be the
place to say it. John does not.
Finally, your approach violates a basic rule of interpretation you
regularly appeal to elsewhere: Scripture interprets Scripture.
When Scripture uses political symbolism, it tells you.
When Scripture means people, it says people.
When Scripture means creation, it says creation.
Here it says:
– heaven
– earth
– sea
Then it says:
– people dwell there
You keep switching the nouns at the conclusion to avoid the force of the
argument. That is not careful reading. That is system protection.
Your analogy may feel reasonable, but God did not give us analogies to
override His words. He gave us words to correct our analogies.
The text does not say “a repaired system.”
The text does not say “a new government.”
The text does not say “cleansed people.”
It says:
– the first heaven passed away
– the first earth passed away
– God made new ones
– righteous people dwell in them
That is what Scripture says.
--
Have you heard the good news Christ died for our sins (†), and God
raised Him from the dead?
That Christ died for our sins shows we're sinners who deserve the death
penalty. That God raised Him from the dead shows Christ's death
satisfied God's righteous demands against our sin (Romans 3:25; 1 John
2:1-2). This means God can now remain just, while forgiving you of your
sins, and saving you from eternal damnation.
On the basis of Christ's death and resurrection for our sins, call on
the name of the Lord to save you: "For 'everyone who calls on the name
of the Lord will be saved'" (Romans 10:13, ESV).
https://christrose.news/salvation
To automatically receive daily Bible teaching updates with colorful
images and website formatting, subscribe to my feed in a client like
Thunderbird:
https://www.christrose.news/feeds/posts/default
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|
