home bbs files messages ]

Forums before death by AOL, social media and spammers... "We can't have nice things"

   alt.religion.christian      Yet another Christian discussion group      8,774 messages   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]

   Message 8,769 of 8,774   
   vjp2.at@at.BioStrategist.dot.dot.co to All   
   Re: ai on liturgy (1/4)   
   24 Feb 26 02:48:45   
   
   I was jsut asking dumb questions, but the result is interesting   
      
   What is the basic structure of the jewish siddhur in terms of psalms,proverbs   
   and scripture as well as other prayers and actions?   
   A siddur can look overwhelming at first glance, but underneath the layers of   
   poetry, blessings, and choreography, its structure is actually very organized.   
   What you???re really seeing is a carefully arranged sequence of biblical   
   passages, psalms,    
   rabbinic prayers, and ritual actions, all woven together to guide daily Jewish   
   prayer.   
      
   Here???s a clear, high???level map of how a traditional siddur is structured,   
   focusing on the role of Psalms, Proverbs, Torah passages, and other core   
   elements.   
      
   1. Morning Service (Shacharit)   
   This is the longest and most structured part of the siddur.   
      
   A. Morning blessings (Birkot HaShachar)   
   Short blessings thanking God for daily functions   
      
   Mostly rabbinic, not biblical   
      
   B. Verses of Praise (Pesukei d???Zimra)   
   This is where Psalms dominate.   
      
   Includes:   
   Psalm 30   
      
   Psalm 100   
      
   Psalms 145???150 (Ashrei + the ???Hallelukahs???)   
      
   Selected verses from Chronicles, Exodus, Nehemiah, etc.   
      
   Purpose: to ???warm up??? spiritually before formal prayer.   
      
   C. Shema and its blessings   
   This section is built around Deuteronomy.   
      
   Includes:   
   Shema (Deut. 6:4)   
      
   V???ahavta (Deut. 6:5???9)   
      
   Vehaya im shamoa (Deut. 11:13???21)   
      
   Vayomer (Num. 15:37???41)   
      
   Surrounded by blessings before and after.   
      
   D. Amidah (Standing Prayer)   
   Central prayer of Jewish worship   
      
   19 blessings (weekday)   
      
   Rabbinic composition, not biblical   
      
   No Psalms or Proverbs here   
      
   E. Concluding prayers   
   Aleinu (late biblical???style prose)   
      
   Psalm of the Day (one psalm assigned to each weekday)   
      
   Kaddish (Aramaic doxology)   
   2. Afternoon Service (Mincha)   
   Much shorter.   
      
   Structure:   
   Opening verses (often from Psalms)   
      
   Amidah   
      
   Aleinu   
      
   Kaddish   
      
   No Shema section here.   
   3. Evening Service (Ma???ariv)   
   Similar to morning but shorter.   
      
   Includes:   
   Blessings around the Shema   
      
   Shema passages (same as morning)   
      
   Amidah   
      
   Aleinu   
      
   Kaddish   
      
   No Pesukei d???Zimra.   
      
    4. Additional Sections in the Siddur   
   A. Psalms (Tehillim)   
   Most siddurim include:   
      
   A full Book of Psalms   
      
   Divided into daily or weekly reading cycles   
      
   B. Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers)   
   This is where Proverbs???like wisdom appears.   
   It???s rabbinic, not biblical, but thematically similar to Proverbs.   
      
   Often read on Shabbat afternoons.   
      
   C. Hallel   
   A festival collection of Psalms:   
      
   Psalms 113???118   
      
   D. Torah readings   
   The siddur includes:   
      
   Blessings before/after Torah reading   
      
   Sometimes the Ten Commandments   
      
   Sometimes the 13 Principles of Faith   
      
   E. Grace After Meals (Birkat HaMazon)   
   Includes:   
      
   Biblical verses (e.g., Deut. 8:10)   
      
   Rabbinic blessings   
      
   F. Bedtime Shema   
   Includes:   
      
   Shema   
      
   Psalm 91   
      
   Psalm 3   
      
   Confessional and protective prayers   
      
    5. Actions and Ritual Movements   
   The siddur also guides physical actions:   
      
   Standing (Amidah)   
      
   Bowing (at certain blessings)   
      
   Covering eyes for Shema   
      
   Wrapping tefillin (weekday mornings)   
      
   Donning tallit   
      
   Taking three steps forward/back   
      
   These are not ???scripture??? but halachic practice embedded in the flow of   
   prayer.   
      
    Summary Table   
   Section	Contains Psalms?	Contains Torah/Scripture?	Contains Proverbs???like   
   material?	Notes   
   Morning blessings	No	No	No	Rabbinic blessings   
   Pesukei d???Zimra	Yes (many)	Some verses	No	Psalm???heavy praise section   
   Shema + blessings	No	Yes (Deut., Num.)	No	Core biblical passages   
   Amidah	No	No	No	Rabbinic core prayer   
   Mincha	Some	No	No	Short service   
   Ma???ariv	Some	Yes (Shema)	No	Evening parallel   
   Hallel	Yes (113???118)	Yes	No	Festivals   
   Pirkei Avot	No	No	Yes (wisdom sayings)	Shabbat afternoons   
   Bedtime Shema	Yes (91, 3)	Yes	No	Night protection prayers   
   If you want, I can also map out:   
      
   The difference between Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Yemenite siddur structures   
      
   How the siddur evolved historically   
      
   A simplified ???flowchart??? for someone learning to navigate it   
      
   Just tell me what direction you???d like to explore.   
      
   How similar is trasitional christian liturgy (eg chryssostom) to the jewish?   
   The short version is this: traditional Christian liturgy???especially the   
   Eastern Orthodox Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom???is structurally very   
   similar to Jewish liturgy, because both grew out of the same ancient Near   
   Eastern prayer culture. They    
   don???t match line???for???line, but the architecture of the service, the flow   
   of psalms and blessings, and even some of the actions feel like close cousins.   
      
   Let me walk you through the parallels in a clear, organized way.   
   1. Overall Structure: Both Are Built Around a Two???Part Service   
   Jewish Liturgy	Christian Liturgy (Chrysostom)	Parallel   
   Shema + blessings + Psalms	Liturgy of the Word	Scripture readings, psalms,   
   hymns   
   Amidah (standing prayer)	Eucharistic Prayer / Anaphora	Central standing prayer   
   Torah reading	Epistle + Gospel reading	Public reading of sacred text   
   Kaddish / Aleinu	Dismissal / Final blessing	Closing doxology   
   The ???two halves??? structure???Word then Sacrifice/Prayer???is inherited   
   directly from the synagogue.   
    2. Use of Psalms   
   Both liturgies are saturated with Psalms.   
      
   Jewish Siddur   
   Pesukei d???Zimra = a chain of Psalms (145???150, 100, 30, etc.)   
      
   Psalm of the Day   
      
   Psalms in Hallel   
      
   Psalms in Bedtime Shema   
      
   Chrysostom Liturgy   
   Antiphons are built from Psalms   
      
   ???Bless the Lord, O my soul??? (Psalm 103)   
      
   ???Only???begotten Son??? hymn follows psalmody   
      
   Communion psalm (often Psalm 148 or 34)   
      
   Why?   
   Because early Christians inherited synagogue chant and psalmody directly.   
      
    3. Blessings and Berakhah Structure   
   Jewish prayer is built from berakhot???short blessings beginning with:   
      
   ???Blessed are You, Lord our God??????   
      
   Christian liturgy preserves the form even if the wording changes.   
      
   Examples of parallel structure:   
   Jewish: ???Blessed are You??? who brings forth bread from the earth.???   
      
   Christian: ???Blessed is the Kingdom??? Blessed is our God always??????   
      
   Eucharistic prayer: ???We give thanks to You, O Lord??????   
      
   The Eucharistic Anaphora is essentially a very long berakhah:   
      
   Praise   
      
   Thanksgiving   
      
   Remembrance   
      
   Petition   
      
   Sanctification   
      
   This is the same structure as the Amidah.   
      
    4. Standing, Bowing, Processions   
   Both traditions include ritual actions:   
      
   Jewish   
   Standing for Amidah   
      
   Bowing at certain blessings   
      
   Torah procession   
      
   Covering eyes for Shema   
      
   Orthodox Christian   
   Standing for most of the service   
      
   Bowing and prostrations   
      
   Gospel procession   
      
   Incense (also used in the Temple)   
      
   These actions reflect shared ancient worship patterns.   
      
    5. Scripture Readings   
   Jewish   
   Torah reading   
      
   Haftarah (Prophets)   
      
   Blessings before and after   
      
   Christian   
   Epistle reading   
      
   Gospel reading   
      
   Litanies and responses   
      
   The Torah reading service is the direct ancestor of the Liturgy of the Word.   
      
    6. Chant and Responsorial Prayer   
   Both traditions use:   
      
   Call???and???response   
      
   Repetitive refrains   
      
   Cantillation of scripture   
      
   Fixed melodies for fixed texts   
      
      
   [continued in next message]   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]


(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca