home bbs files messages ]

Forums before death by AOL, social media and spammers... "We can't have nice things"

   alt.comp.software.seamonkey      Not a bad little Mozilla fork      9,710 messages   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]

   Message 9,398 of 9,710   
   NFN Smith to Jota.Ce   
   Re: Doubts about SeaMonkey Mail: Exchang   
   05 Nov 25 09:25:05   
   
   From: worldoff9908@gmail.com   
      
   Jota.Ce wrote:   
      
   >   
   > Anyway... Last year, SeaMonkey Mail worked without problems with   
   > institutional mail account (MS 365 ecosystem). Since we are jailed,   
   > SeaMonkey can't retrieve/send mails, but i can't really know why. Maybe   
   > they are blocking the port? At home, that settings work as expected.   
   >   
   > Outlook works, ThunderBird works if i choose Exchange account, but not   
   > if i choose POP acount (didn't try on IMAP).   
   >   
   > What could i do? Can SeaMonkey use Exchange mail servers? Can SeaMonkey   
   > "steal" a ThunderBird account copying some files/folders? Is there   
   > anything i can test/try? Is there any logs i could see to point to some   
   > clue?   
      
   As noted elsewhere in this thread, Seamonkey has no problems with   
   Microsoft servers for POP and IMAP.  Beyond the basic settings for IMAP   
   (server=outlook.office365.com, Port=993, your user ID and password and   
   Connection Security=SSL/TLS) the key difference is in setting the   
   Authentication Method to OAuth2.   
      
   When you make a first setup of a Microsoft account and you use the setup   
   wizard, after you enter all settings correctly, at the end of the   
   process, you should see a Microsoft-branded pop-up that requests your   
   password a second time.  After you enter the password the second time,   
   then an OAuth2 token is created and saved in your passwords store.   
   That's the way that it's supposed to work, but there are sometimes   
   complications.   
      
   I've found that sometimes, things don't work -- it seems to be that   
   there are occasions when there's some sort of corruption related to the   
   saved OAuth2 token. If that happens, then the thing to do is to go into   
   the password manager and delete any OAuth2 tokens for that account, and   
   a subsequent connection attempt should generate a new Microsoft pop-up.   
      
   Noted elsewhere in this thread is justification for OAuth2 and "Modern   
   Authentication" that includes the eye-rolling "for your security".  In   
   this case, it's not just Microsoft's paternalistic attitude toward   
   users, but a real security enhancement, a way of doing 2-Factor   
   Authentication, where the "something you have" is the OAuth2 token that   
   has been saved.  If you do setups in multiple places (e.g., a second   
   profile, another mail client, another computer, etc.) each one will need   
   to have a unique OAuth2 token, and I believe that if you copy a profile   
   (e.g., transfer to a new computer), you have to delete any saved OAuth2   
   tokens and let them be recreated.   
      
   A further item with Microsoft servers is that they have a structure that   
   allows for Shared accounts.  In that, if an account is designated as   
   shared, then it has a list of email addresses that are allowed to   
   interact with that account. From there, it is possible to set up a   
   connection to the shared account that shows up in Seamonkey as just   
   another mail account.  It takes a little tinkering with the setup   
   process to correctly generate the proper OAuth2 token, but it does work,   
   and the result is that there is no sharing of passwords for the shared   
   account. From the side of administrator, it's easy to grant or deny   
   access to the shared account for specific users, and the admins have   
   full logging, knowing who is using the account and access details.   
      
   For what it's worth, use of OAuth2 isn't limited to Microsoft. Google is   
   doing that with Gmail, and it's getting common with other providers.   
   Some may allow for "application password" that is different from the   
   password you use for an interactive connection, but OAuth2 is becoming a   
   standard.   
      
   However, for your issue, I don't believe that OAuth2 handling is the   
   problem, nor port issues, nor a config setting that can be borrowed from   
   Thunderbird. It's a structural issue that is beyond the current   
   capacities of Seamonkey. Besides POP and IMAP, Exchange is a different   
   protocol that is specific to Microsoft servers, and where that's used   
   with Microsoft-specific applications that are tightly integrated with   
   the various tools that are bundled in the Outlook client. Not just   
   email, but calendar, as well.  Thus, something like a contact management   
   database that allows generation and storage of email and tracking of   
   calendar activities.   
      
   Unfortunately, if an account is configured as an Exchange account on the   
   server, you have to be using a client that supports Exchange   
   connections. Obviously, Microsoft assumes use of Outlook. I know that   
   Apple Mail supports Exchange, and I believe that it's still possible   
   with Evolution (although more difficult than it used to be).   
   Thunderbird is working on direct support, although that's something that   
   is evolving with successive mainstream releases (and not the ESR track),   
   and it's not fully active yet -- I don't see that being truly "ready for   
   prime time" until at least the turnover of the next ESR cycle next June.   
      
   The one way that I know that it's possible to get Thunderbird to   
   interact with Exchange is through a paid extension called OWL. But until   
   Thunderbird completes its own work for Exchange support, OWL may be the   
   only reliable option.   
      
   For you, it seems that the Exchange server has been configured to allow   
   only Exchange connections, and it's entirely possible that they've   
   disabled IMAP and POP.  If that's the case, I agree that it sucks,   
   especially if you don't have any felt need to do all the interaction   
   with the Microsoft stack, and only want the ability to send and receive   
   mail.   
      
   But if the server is configured to not allow POP or IMAP connections,   
   and requires everything to be done with Exchange connections, then using   
   Seamonkey is not an option now, and probably never will be.  In   
   Thunderbird, the process for adding Exchange support has been a   
   several-year project, and I'm doubtful that the maintainers of Seamonkey   
   have the resources to replicate. And even with OWL, that won't be   
   possible in Seamonkey unless/until Seamonkey is able to support   
   WebExtensions, something that is also not expected any time in the near   
   future.   
      
   For your particular situation, your options are probably limited to   
   using Outlook, or using Thunderbird, whether the Exchange support is   
   mature enough in the main release version, or paying for OWL.   
      
   Smith   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]


(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca