From: bob4tull@aol.com   
      
   On Sat, 13 Nov 2010 16:00:43 -0500, Missy Roos Walker wrote:   
      
   > First, Tom did a fine job reviewing the movie. He also included a   
   > disclaimer, so stop attacking him and read the disclaimer. Half of you   
   > are just making yourselves look like idiots saying things that he made   
   > very clear at the beginning of the review.   
   >   
   > Secondly, unless you did read the book and are a fan, the second half   
   > of the movie probably does play rather dull. I love the book and the   
   > movies, and even I though the running around the woods could have been   
   > shortened. And again, unless you read the books, the "love triangle"   
   > is exactly that - two males arguing over one female.   
   >   
   > And thirdly, it may be the first half of a book, but a) the trailers   
   > play up the action without saying where the action takes place and b)   
   > EVERY movie needs to stand on its own and sadly, these movies will not   
   > do so. Every movie needs a beginning, middle and end. These movies   
   > will not have that because they are one book, split in half and just   
   > because you know that, does not mean when the movie ends, you will be   
   > satisfied, fan or not.   
      
   Tom did do an exceptional review for someon with limited knowledge. I   
   have to think he (along with a lot of other reviewers) is counting   
   this as one film. It's not. It's part 1 of a two part film. Of course   
   it will feel empty and leaves the audience cheated because it is not   
   over. Not all movies have to have a beginning, middle and end. If the   
   part 1 is included in the name like this one is then a normal human   
   being would realize that this isnt the whole story. Why would you   
   conclude this film? Then there would be no need for parts.   
      
   Also, I feel as if Tom didn't really see the film as a reviewer. I   
   feel he went in only to point out the flaws. He wasn't there to   
   appreciate what worked.   
      
   As someone who didn't read the last book this review will appeal to   
   people that aren't fans if the series. But, I feel that this shouldn't   
   be counted down for things such as incomplete story or dragging when   
   it is clear that a part 2 is coming. Also I find it hard to believe Ed   
   and care for what he has written when he has spelling errors and   
   errors on the franchise in general.   
   >   
   > oh yeah.   
   >   
   > blow me.   
      
   You wish.   
      
   >  http://tr.im/1f7r   
      
   OK, I'll blow you. :)   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)