1e92be15   
   XPost: alt.religion   
   From: DONTvictordix@imapmail.orgSPAMME   
      
   On Wed, 26 Jan 2011 18:53:39 -0800 (PST), SPT wrote:   
      
   > Ok, let's stop confusing the movies with the books.   
      
   It makes no difference to the Subject of this thread whether we are   
   considering the books or the movies. I quote myself once again: "Once   
   you remove Rowling's Christianity, and her admitted use of it in   
   delivering the HP books, then you are allowed any conjecture   
   whatsoever as you have here".   
      
   "Again, this is the fundamental difference in our approaches. I stand   
   by mine since it is prescribed and subscribed by the author herself."   
      
   IOW, there is no value in rehashing either your position on this or   
   mine or any discussions that accrue from them.   
      
   > Now to your observation about the Granger's house. It is meaningless.   
   > In the first place, I never asserted that Hermione was Jewish. I   
   > merely stated that it could not be ruled out.   
      
   I clearly stated that "I saw nothing that would indicate that she was   
   Jewish."   
      
   > So the fact that there is no menorah on her mantlepiece is   
   > completely irrelevant to me; it *still* doesn't rule anything out   
   > AND Hermione's religion is not important anyway.   
      
   All religious beliefs would be important to this discussion regarding   
   Rowling, the Gringotts as Jews and similar topics.   
      
   We are standing on two sides of different tables.   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)