XPost: rec.arts.books.tolkien   
   From: invalid@microsoft.com   
      
   O. Sharp brought next idea :   
   > Michael Cole  writes:   
   >>>> A passage, phrase or sentence from the books...   
   >>>> 1. From Lord of the Rings?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 2.  From the "Fellowship of the Ring"?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>> 3. Spoken or containing speech?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 4. Appearing exactly once?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 5. Spoken by Gandalf? No.   
   >>>> 6. Spoken by a member of the Fellowship?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>> 7. In English (as appearing in the book)?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 8.  Spoken to a hobbit?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>> 9.Were any of the Fellowship present?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 10.  Any of the Fellowship who were not Men?  (Referring to   
   >>>> species, not gender.)   
   >>>> Assuming this question to be, were any Elf, Dwarf, Hobbit or   
   >>>> Maia members of the Fellowship present?   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 11.  Was Gandalf present?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>> 12. Spoken by a Man? (the race of Men, not the gender)   
   >>>> Yes.   
   >>>> 13.  Spoken by a Rohirrim?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>> 14. Were Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli all present?   
   >>>> No.   
   >>>>> 15. Was a Hobbit present (which is a somewhat different question   
   >>>>> than #8)?   
   >>>> It is different, and has a different answer.  Yes.   
   >>> 16. Was Pippin present?   
   >> No.   
   >   
   > 17. Was any member of the Fellowship OTHER than Frodo and/or Sam present?   
      
   No.   
      
      
   > -------------------------------------------------------------------   
   > ohh@panix.com        And no fair using the "Faramir Was An Honorary   
   >         Member Of The Fellowship, At Least In Spirit" argument.  :)   
      
   I wouldn't do that :-)   
      
   --   
   Michael Cole   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)