XPost: rec.arts.books.tolkien
From: invalid@microsoft.com
Michael Ikeda formulated on Friday :
> Michael Cole wrote in news:j1v6m1$gbh$1
> @dont-email.me:
>
>> on 11/08/2011, Michael Ikeda supposed :
>>> Michael Cole wrote in
>>> news:j1tor3$88i$1@dont-email.me:
>>>
>>>> [Reposting this to both newsgroups]
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> A passage, phrase or sentence from the books...
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 1. From Lord of the Rings?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2. From the "Fellowship of the Ring"?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3. Spoken or containing speech?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 4. Appearing exactly once?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 5. Spoken by Gandalf? No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 6. Spoken by a member of the Fellowship?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 7. In English (as appearing in the book)?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 8. Spoken to a hobbit?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 9.Were any of the Fellowship present?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 10. Any of the Fellowship who were not Men?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> (Referring to species, not gender.)
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Assuming this question to be, were any Elf, Dwarf,
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hobbit or Maia members of the Fellowship present? Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 11. Was Gandalf present?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No. 12. Spoken by a Man? (the race of Men, not the
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> gender) Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 13. Spoken by a Rohirrim?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 14. Were Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli all present?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 15. Was a Hobbit present (which is a somewhat
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> different question than #8)?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> It is different, and has a different answer. Yes.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 16. Was Pippin present?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>>>> 17. Was any member of the Fellowship OTHER than Frodo
>>>>>>>>>>>>> and/or Sam present?
>>>>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>>>> 18. Spoken by someone who would usually be classed as
>>>>>>>>>>> 'good'?
>>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>> 19. Spoken by Faramir?
>>>>>>>> I was going to ask this! ...but didn't know if lurkers were
>>>>>>>> allowed.
>>>>>>> Lurkers are totally allowed. And to answer the question, No.
>>>>>> 20. Spoken during the time between Frodo and Sam standing
>>>>>> before the Morannon and standing before the bridge to Minas
>>>>>> Morgul?
>>>>> Yes. Although not for the entire time - that would be one long
>>>>> speech...
>>> 21. Spoken before Frodo and Sam reach Henneth Annun?
>> Yes.
22. Spoken by Sméagol?
No.
> 23. Is the speaker named?
Yes.
--
Michael Cole
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|
