XPost: rec.arts.books.tolkien   
   From: mmikeda@erols.com   
      
   Joanne Corsano  wrote in   
   news:rae757tun3igqfu2jjfbdhj3er8s0hn2f5@4ax.com:   
      
   >>>>>> An action performed in the books.   
   >>>>>> 1. Performed by a single person?   
   >>>>>> Yes.   
   >>>>>> 2.  By a member of the Fellowship?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 3. Does the action have to be directed towards someone   
   >>>>>> or something?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 4. could this action be successfully performed (with its   
   >>>>>> desired results) in our "real" world?   
   >>>>>> Yes.   
   >>>>>> 5. Performed only once in all the Tolkien books?   
   >>>>>> Yes. (To clarify, this particular action is performed   
   >>>>>> once. Similar actions are performed other times; but I   
   >>>>>> am thinking of a specific occurrence.)   
   >>>>>> 6.  Is the action in LoTR?   
   >>>>>> Yes.   
   >>>>>> 7.  In "The Fellowship of the Ring"?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 8. Is the person alone at the time?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 9.  Is the person from the race of Men?   
   >>>>>> Partly.   
   >>>>>> 10. Performed by Elrond?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 11.  In "The Two Towers"?   
   >>>>>> No.   
   >>>>>> 12. Within or within sight of the city walls of Minas   
   Tirith?   
   >>>>> No.   
   >>>> 13. Are any of the Fellowship present at the time?   
   >>> Yes.   
   >>> 14. Performed by Arwen, then?   
   >>> Yes.   
   >>15. Did the action involve speaking or singing?   
   > No.   
   16.  Is the action in the main text of LoTR (as opposed to, for   
   example, the Appendices)?   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)