541c3f68   
   XPost: rec.arts.books.tolkien   
   From: mmikeda@erols.com   
      
   Christopher Kreuzer  wrote in   
   news:2b608b15-83bf-4a2e-b865-adbc1579281a@z8g2000yqe.googlegroups.c   
   om:   
      
   > A place:   
   > 1. Mentioned in Lord of the Rings?   
   > Yes   
   > 2. In Middle-Earth?   
   > Yes   
   > 3. Mentioned in "The Fellowship of the Ring"?   
   > Yes   
   > 4. Visited during the narrative of 'Lord of the Rings' by one   
   > or more mem   
   > ber(s) of the Fellowship?   
   > Yes (*)   
   > 5.  Visited by an intact Fellowship?   
   > No (**)   
   > 6. West of Anduin?   
   > No   
   > 7.  Visited by Sam?   
   > Yes (*)   
   > 8. Does Sam's "visit" to this place take place in the   
   > 'Fellowship of the   
   > Ring'?   
   > Yes   
   > 9. Is it (a part of) Lothlorien?   
   > No   
   > 10. Is (or was) this place (at least sometime) inhabited by men   
   > or orcs? No (***)   
   > 11. Is it a body of water?   
   >Yes   
   > 12. Is it the River Anduin?   
   > No.   
   13.  Is it a specific location in the River Anduin?   
      
   >   
   > Notes:   
   > * (1) 'Visit' means "being in the general region of this place".   
   > ** (2) 'Intact' Fellowship means 'complete' (i.e. all nine   
   > Companions present).   
   > *** (3) 'Place' means being listed under 'Places' in the Index   
   > (not all are habitable).   
   >   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)