XPost: rec.arts.books.tolkien
From: invalid@microsoft.com
Michael Ikeda formulated on Friday :
> Michael Cole wrote in
> news:j757cu$haq$1@dont-email.me:
>
>> Dworkin wrote :
>>> On 12 okt, 00:55, Michael Cole wrote:
>>>> Michael Ikeda presented the following explanation :
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>> Michael Cole wrote in
>>>>> news:j6tb1o$tco$1@dont-email.me:
>>>>>> on 9/10/2011, Tahi supposed :
>>>>>>>>> Again, a passage, phrase or sentence from the
>>>>>>>>> books...
>>>>>>>>> 1. In LoTR?
>>>>>>>>> No. 2. The Hobbit? No.
>>>>>>>>> 3. In Unfinished Tales?
>>>>>>>>> Yes
>>>>>>>>> 4. Is the passage something that is spoken by a
>>>>>>>>> character?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>> 5. Does it describe something?
>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>> 6. Is the description connected to Beleriand?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>> 7. Is the description connected to Numenor?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>> 8. Is the description connected to the Third Age?
>>>>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>>>>>> 9 About the Palantiri?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>> 10. A description of a living creature?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>>>> 11. About something geographic, like a river, a valley, a
>>>>>>>>> cave, a mountain?
>>>>>>>>> No.
>>>>>>> 12.Does it describe what is being seen by a person (or
>>>>>>> people)?
>>>>>> Yes.
>>>>> 13. Seen by one person (as opposed to a group)?
>>>> No.
>>> 14. Elendil's tomb?
>> No.
> 15. A description of an object created by one or more beings
> belonging to one or more of the Free Peoples (that is, elves,
> humans, hobbits, dwarves, or ents).
Oooh. This is going to depend on the definition of "an object", but I
am going to say, Yes.
--
Michael Cole
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|
