XPost: alt.abortion, alt.abortion.inequity, alt.atheism   
   XPost: alt.support.abortion, talk.abortion   
   From: nachobiznez@all.com   
      
   "Robert B. Winn"  wrote in message   
   news:7943568.0405172251.28266230@posting.google.com...   
   > "MrD"  wrote in message   
   news:...   
   > > "Attila"  wrote in message   
   > > news:7rria0lp7osgmioqnav2300rqvpe8o9os2@4ax.com...   
   > > > On Mon, 17 May 2004 21:06:04 -0500, "MrD"  in   
   > > > alt.abortion with message-id  wrote:   
   > > >   
   > > > >   
   > > > >"Attila"  wrote in message   
   > > > >news:d5aia01l6381ehqmsrr201uuqo3ggddkk8@4ax.com...   
   > > > >> On Mon, 17 May 2004 14:28:45 -0500, "MrD"  in   
   > > > >> alt.abortion with message-id  wrote:   
   > > > >>   
   > > > >> >   
   > > > >> >"Attila"  wrote in message   
   > > > >> >news:eljha0dqpuldic5ub1qgt5qes1npitg7ti@4ax.com...   
   > > > >> >> On Mon, 17 May 2004 07:52:43 -0500, "MrD"    
   in   
   > > > >> >> alt.abortion with message-id    
   wrote:   
   > > > >> >>   
   > > > >> >> >   
   > > > >> >> >"Attila"  wrote in message   
   > > > >> >> >news:4kbha0dqhovsr8bqlmadf5as4c2ov6bhh1@4ax.com...   
   > > > >> >> >> On Mon, 17 May 2004 06:38:18 -0500, "MrD"   
      
   > >  in   
   > > > >> >> >> alt.abortion with message-id    
   > >  wrote:   
   > > > >> >> >>   
   > > > >> >> >> >>   
   > > > >> >> >> >> I don't write lies.  Why don't you just show that atheists   
   are   
   > >  not   
   > > > >> >> >> >> forbidden to discuss Hezekiah's tunnel by discussing it?   
   > > > >> >> >> >   
   > > > >> >> >> >I already have, so your argument is a total disgrace to your   
   > >  honor.   
   > > > >> >> >> >I'm happy to discuss the tunnel that you think is   
   Hezekiah's.   
   > >  The   
   > >  problem   
   > > > >> >> >> >is that you aren't able to discuss it honestly.   
   > > > >> >> >> >   
   > > > >> >> >>   
   > > > >> >> >> I would still like to know who it is that forbids atheists to   
   > >  discuss   
   > > > >> >> >> anything but I suppose I will never find out.   
   > > > >> >> >   
   > > > >> >> >It's forbidden to discuss?   
   > > > >> >> >   
   > > > >> >>   
   > > > >> >> That is what the Winnut keeps saying.   
   > > > >> >>   
   > > > >> >> "Why don't you just show that atheists are not   
   > > > >> >> forbidden to discuss Hezekiah's tunnel by discussing it?"   
   > > > >> >>   
   > > > >> >I'm perfectly willing to discuss this tunnel, how about you?   
   > > > >> >   
   > > > >>   
   > > > >> Do you mean discuss it with me or the Winnut?   
   > > > >>   
   > > > >> I know nothing about it but that hasn't stopped me in the past.    
   > > > >>   
   > > > >Winnut, as you call him, set forward an experiment whereas we can   
   show   
   > >  that   
   > > > >atheists aren't forbidden to discuss Hezekiah's supposed tunnel by   
   > > > >discussing it.  Here we are discussing it.  Guess he's got his   
   result.   
   > > > >I've read just a bit about it and it's pretty clear that it's old,   
   but   
   > >  it's   
   > > > >disconcerting to find an inscription by the diggers that didn't give   
   some   
   > > > >homage to the king if he was so inspired as to tell them to dig in   
   such a   
   > > > >way that had never been tried before.  This was a first, a totally   
   > > > >horizontal dig from two start points, connecting up.  If Hezekiah had   
   > > > >ordered it, he would have been praised all over the place for the   
   > >  insight.   
   > > > >I think it was someone much more common who thought it wise to follow   
   the   
   > > > >fissure in the rock  that leaked water to the pool during the higher   
   > >  water   
   > > > >periods.   
   > > > >Wow, we are just discussing away on this tunnel.   
   > > > >   
   > > >   
   > > > I agree a new engineering method that yielded such useful results   
   > > > would have not only been mentioned but emulated,  The King, in fact,   
   > > > would have wanted to get as much credit as possible by advertising   
   > > > such a useful method far and wide.  It is much more likely someone   
   > > > simply followed the water to see where it came from.   
   > > >   
   > > > One problem with those pesky tunnels is how hard it is to be certain   
   > > > exactly when they were built.   
   > > >   
   > > > I am still waiting for someone to forbid me to discuss this, but so   
   > > > far I have detected nothing.  Perhaps it's another one of those pesky   
   > > > gods who is failing his responsibilities.   
   > > >   
   > > I, too, seem unable to find anyone who is able to forbid me to discuss   
   this   
   > > tunnel.   
   > > I guess Wicked Winn is just Whack.   
   >   
   > Well, the problem with that is that you have not discussed it with me.   
   >  I would still have to believe that your leader satan does not want it   
   > discussed with me.   
      
   Switching the goals, eh Robert?   You stated that atheists were  apparently   
   forbidden to discuss it.  I have shown that atheists have no trouble   
   discussing it.  I have even discussed it with you.  Therefore your entire   
   'satan' argument is shown to be fatally flawed.  Much like your character.   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)