XPost: alt.abortion, alt.abortion.inequity, alt.atheism   
   XPost: alt.support.abortion, talk.abortion   
   From: nachobiznez@all.com   
      
   "Robert B. Winn"  wrote in message   
   news:7943568.0405270539.459c7c98@posting.google.com...   
   > "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   news:...   
   > > While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > news:7943568.0405260525.1706b2d1@posting.google.com,   
   > >  he or she gave us all a good laugh with the   
   > > following...   
   > >   
   > > > "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   > > > news:...   
   > > >> While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > >> news:7943568.0405251652.562316f5@posting.google.com,   
   > > >>  he or she gave us all a good laugh with   
   > > >> the following...   
   > > >>   
   > > >>> "MrD"  wrote in message   
   > > >>> news:...   
   > > >>>> "Robert B. Winn"  wrote in message   
   > > >>>> news:7943568.0405242020.1bca92f1@posting.google.com...   
   > > >>>>> "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   > >  news:...   
   > > >>>>>> While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > >>>>>> news:7943568.0405240459.5d30087@posting.google.com,   
   > > >>>>>>  he or she gave us all a good laugh   
   > > >>>>>> with the following...   
   > > >>>>>>   
   > > >>>>>>> "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   > > >>>>>>> news:...   
   > > >>>>>>>> While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > >>>>>>>> news:7943568.0405231553.24124a86@posting.google.com,   
   > > >>>>>>>>  he or she gave us all a good laugh   
   > > >>>>>>>> with the following...   
   > > >>>>>>>>   
   > > >>>>>>>>> "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   > > >>>>>>>>>   
   news:...   
   > > >>>>>>>>>> While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > >>>>>>>>>> news:7943568.0405222207.26467285@posting.google.com,   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>  he or she gave us all a good laugh   
   > > >>>>>>>>>> with the following...   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>> "Light Templar"  wrote in message   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>>   
   news:...   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>>> While Robert B. Winn was contemplating his or her navel in   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>>> news:7943568.0405221613.484172e8@posting.google.com,   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>>>  he or she gave us all a good   
   > > >>>>>>>>>>>> laugh with the following...   
   > >   
   > > >>>> If all the scientists did agree that the tunnel was 500 years older   
   > > >>>> than Hezekiah, you would not believe them anyway.  You would call   
   > > >>>> the mountains down upon you and beg the rocks to hide you from any   
   > > >>>> proof that the tunnel is older than Heziekiah.   
   > > >>>> You know you would.   
   > > >>>   
   > > >>> No, it is obvious that the inscription was written by the workers   
   > > >>> who dug it from what they wrote.   
   > > >>   
   > > >> Prove it.   
   > > >>   
   > > >>   
   > > >>> That being the case, how could it have   
   > > >>> been written 500 years later?   
   > > >>   
   > > >> The Tunnel may have been built 500 years earlier, and Hezekiah took   
   > > >> credit, or it could have been a later forgery.   
   > > >   
   > > > So you believe that people back then were as dishonest as you are.   
   > >   
   > > No Robert, I'm saying that they were as dishonest as you are.   And   
   brother,   
   > > that's really dishonest!   
   >   
   > Well, explain something to me.  Why does the inscription just describe   
   > the digging of the tunnel, the voice of the worker calling through the   
   > crack in the rock, the height of the rock over the tunnel, the water   
   > running through the tunnel, etc, instead of the year, the name of the   
   > king, the political situation, and the difference in the patina if the   
   > workers did not make the inscription?  Why would anyone else write   
   > what was written?  Do you think that someone was trying to give the   
   > false impression that they worked on the tunnel?   
      
   I guess Winn never considered that the original description of the digging   
   could have been recorded on something less durable and was later copied into   
   the actual stone of the tunnel.  Afterall, I doubt that the laborers who   
   were simply hacking out a tunnel had the stone cutting skills to be   
   inscribers.  Different skill levels and class of worker entirely.  The tale   
   could have been handed down through generations before someone thought to   
   venerate it by carving it into stone.   
   I don't think he'll see this reply, he's never been able to reply to   
   anything that has the subject line changed to immoral Winn.   
   I suggest everyone adopt this way of replying to him and he'll be gone,   
   poof, obliterated by ignoring his original thread.   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)