From: owl2@herandnow.com
What about the crap chorus vocal arrangement ?
I defy anyone who doesn't have the lyrics/be a dan fan/ etc to decipher what
the hell he's on about the key also sounds off ....FFS !
Jim
Apart from that....... almost decent - but certainly no nightfly !
"R-ton" wrote in message
news:534cg.439123$xc7.11704365@phobos.telenet-ops.be...
> Hello,
>
> after two months listening to MTC, the CD, I am able to give some
> comments
> now.
>
> I gave scores to all tracks the day after I purchased it ; not at first
> ,
> but at second listening. This one got 7/10 at that moment.
> Now I give new scores, without looking at the first score. It's 8.5/10
> now.
>
> Specific comments :
>
> *) From the first seconds, my impression was : "waw this is really an SD
> song" (which, in fact, it isn't...) . Especially, the flanged Rhodes sound
> is so typical...
> *) The bass riff is very strong, and consistently repeated or varied
> during
> the song.
> *) Excellent vocals during chorus
> *) This song, contains almost no syncopes -- remarkable / rare !
> *) The guitar solo from 4:06 is very strong, very well building-up however
> -) it is spoiled by the background muted trumpet. Personally, I don't
> like
> at all the sound of a muted trumpet. And, it's a pity that the sound is
> used in more tracks on the album. Without that trumpet, the song would
> definitely deserve a 9/10.
>
> *)The reprise is in fact nothing more than a chorus and a quite solo
> which,
> fortunately, ends without the muted trumpet.
> *)The end of the reprise is very very strange, in a key totally different
> from the song.
> It reminds me of the first notes of "Jerusalem", by Hubert Parry.
>
> Any comments or other ideas on these tracks welcome !! !!
> If the idea seems positive, I suggest to discuss track 2 next week.
>
> R-ton
> Belgium
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|
