home bbs files messages ]

Forums before death by AOL, social media and spammers... "We can't have nice things"

   alt.philosophy      Didn't Freud have sex with his mother?      170,348 messages   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]

   Message 168,688 of 170,348   
   Ilya Shambat to All   
   Good feminism and bad feminism   
   28 Sep 23 19:31:13   
   
   From: ibshambat@gmail.com   
      
   When feminism went bad, there were people saying that people should remain a   
   part of it because prior to that feminism has done right things.   
      
   This is like Putin saying that people should support his war in Ukraine   
   because in the past he has been a decent leader.   
      
   For a long time feminism was a good cause. It fought for right things –   
   women’s right to a safe life inside the home and a fulfilling life outside   
   the home. Then it went bad and started telling women that they can’t be   
   beautiful, that they can’t    
   be kind and that they can’t have loving relationships with men. This   
   resulted in many people who otherwise would have been part of feminism   
   rejecting feminism. And I have been one of these people.   
      
   I have a teenage daughter. I most certainly don’t want her to wind up a   
   punching bag for some jerk. But neither do I want her to be abused by   
   feminists for being kind and pretty. Neither situation would be right. And I   
   will inform her about both    
   dangers so that she can avoid either experience.   
      
   For as long as there are men who choose to be jerks, there will be a need for   
   one or another form of feminism. I want the form of feminism being practiced   
   to be the right kind. It should fight for the woman’s right to a safe life   
   inside the home and a    
   fulfilling life outside the home. On other issues, it needs to move away from   
   its errors. In particular it needs to stop teaching women to be horrible   
   people. Women gain nothing from that and lose the sympathy of both men and   
   other women.   
      
   One situation instructive to American feminists is the situation in Sweden. In   
   Sweden feminism is more advanced than it is in America; but women are not   
   under pressure to be ugly and mean. The Swedish women are very beautiful, and   
   they are also kind and    
   friendly. They get more respect than American women. Which means that American   
   feminists have a lot to learn from them.   
      
   So we have American feminists teaching their followers to be horrible people.   
   And – surprise surprise – what happens but that American men are looking   
   outside of America to places like Russia for marital partners. This makes   
   sense on both sides. The    
   American man stands to get treated much better by a Russian woman than by an   
   American feminist, and the Russian woman stands to be treated much better by   
   an American man than by a Russian man. This results in better people having   
   better relationships.    
   And it also results in an incentive on the offending gender in each society to   
   improve their treatment of the other gender, or else see the other gender   
   leave in large numbers to be with people who are willing to be good to them.   
      
   There is good feminism and there is bad feminism. The Swedish version of   
   feminism is much better than the American version. Anything human can go right   
   and anything human can go wrong. It does not make sense to either support or   
   oppose all of feminism.    
   It makes sense to support what feminism is right about and oppose what it is   
   wrong about.   
      
   When a movement goes wrong, it discredits even the things that it has been   
   right about. Abuses of feminism have discredited feminism as such. So now   
   there are men who keep claiming that Western misogynists have been right all   
   along and that women are    
   evil and should be battered. This did not need to have happened. This happened   
   because feminism went wrong.   
      
   Choosing whether or not to side with a movement is a matter of freedom of   
   conscience. A conscientious man supports what the movement is right about and   
   confronts what it is wrong about. I don’t need to support wrongs in feminism   
   to be in favor of womenâ   
   €™s rights. I support what’s right in feminism and confront what’s wrong   
   in feminism. And I hope that other people make the same choice.   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]


(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca