Forums before death by AOL, social media and spammers... "We can't have nice things"
|    alt.philosophy    |    Didn't Freud have sex with his mother?    |    170,348 messages    |
[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]
|    Message 168,776 of 170,348    |
|    Ilya Shambat to All    |
|    Libertarianism and private corruption    |
|    30 Oct 23 19:14:51    |
      From: ibshambat@gmail.com              Libertarians, objectivists and some conservatives all make the same error.       They see federal government as an organ of corruption and oppression, and       nobody else as such.              In fact there are many organs of corruption and oppression that aren't the       federal government. Violent husbands. Oppressive religions. Suffocating       communities. Corrupt networks in law and medicine. In Western countries, these       exercise far greater levels        of corruption and oppression than does the federal government.              In Western countries, the governments are elected, official, and made       accountable to the public. The same is not the case for these other entities.       This results in them having an unchecked potential for brutal, corrupt and       oppressive practices. And while        the libertarians are out there hunting for corruption potentials in the       federal government, real corruption sprouts up under their noses and puts them       in its service.              You may ask my friend Celeste, an MD who had three of her relatives murdered       in American medical health system. Corrupt doctors enlisted corrupt coroners       and corrupt lawyers to bury the evidence and draw away from her any lawyer       that she would hire. Or        you may ask any number of women who escaped serious domestic violence in the       American South, only to see the courts award their children to the       perpetrators. Or you may ask someone I know who tried to escape from       Jehovah's Witnesses, only to see his        family commit him indefinitely in a mental hospital and manipulate him to       become hateful and abusive to his loving and generous girlfriend.              Biden did not do this. Corrupt local entities did.              What is more worthy of authority: An entity that is official, accountable,       checked and balanced, or entities that are unofficial, unaccountable,       unbalanced and unchecked? There is no official check on the power of       communities and religions. There is no        official check on the power of corrupt entities in law and medicine. There is       no official check on the power of Jehovah's Witnesses. The problem gets no       attention at all from the libertarians, as they spend all their time and       energy scrutinizing the        federal government. And thile they are out there spouting New World Order       conspiracy theories and claiming “statism” or “socialism,” real       corruption and real oppression grows up in their hometowns. The entities that       are responsible for this        corruption, being the manipulative little shits that they are, then,       ridiculously, direct the energies of the libertarians toward fighting those in       the government who seek to fight this corruption under the false – and       ridiculous – claim that in        doing so they are protecting values and freedom.              Values and freedom that they violate to a far greater extent than does the       federal government; and which violations, with the energies of the       scrutinizers spent on the federal government, goes unnoticed and unchecked.              That an entity is unofficial does not make it any less capable of corruption       and oppression than the official entities. Indeed, being unofficial, it is       un-scrutinized; which gives it an unlimited potential for corruption and       oppression. This is the case        with the doctors who murdered Celeste's relatives; this is the case with the       community courts that award children to child rapists and batterers; this is       the case with Jehovah's Witnesses; this is the case with many others.              A person truly interested in defending liberty and integrity will do so from       all entities that infringe on these things, whether they be official or       unofficial. A true libertarian will be just as willing to take on private       corruption and oppression as to        take on public corruption and oppression. Once they do, they will have earned       their title as defenders of freedom. And until they do, they are cowards and       hypocrites who attack an entity that is easy to attack while doing nothing to       fight real wrongs.              --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05        * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)    |
[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]
(c) 1994, bbs@darkrealms.ca