From: davideml@bellsouth.net
"poker88" wrote in message
news:1192727727.896049.62660@v29g2000prd.googlegroups.com...
> On Oct 17, 9:52 am, "Ahroo" wrote:
>> I can't believe you gave it a 7.5!!! Higher than A Family Affair? Higher
>> than A Good Day? ALMOST as good as ASITST, ISAIH, LUATD, and Crusader??? I
>> started to rewatch it yesterday and couldn't force myself to get much past
>> about halfway through. I thought it was silly, stupid, and just plain
>> ridiculous. Worthy of being a season 5 episode! Best I can do is an
>> overly-generous 4. It really should be a 3, but I guess I am reserving that
>> rating for some of what I know is coming up next season. I don't mind the
>> fact that it was a comedy - if you recall from season 3, some of my all-time
>> favorite episodes are comedies. But this was not funny to me at all - just
>> lame.
>
>
> LOL! I have to agree. I couldn't even get my nieces and nephew to
> finish watching this one and they love Joxer. Guess without Xena or
> Gabby it didn't hold the same appeal for them (or for me). This one
> is definitely not better than A Good Day or even A Family Affair
> (which I consider cheesy but likeable ). That just my opinion
> though. It's OK if David liked this one better than the others.
>
As I said a few times before, I never much liked A Good Day. Even
though it didn't seem as
terrible the last time I watched it, it is down in the bottom five of my least
liked eps.
Also, A Family Affair left me hungry for actual explanations for the
things that preceded
it --
"somehow this episode left me dissatisfied and feeling like maybe there were
some crucial
explanatory scenes cut out."
But I never expect everyone to agree with my ratings and feelings
about ANY episode.
David
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)
|
