XPost: misc.phone.mobile.iphone, comp.sys.mac.misc   
   From: mariasophia@comprehension.com   
      
   Your Name wrote:   
   >    
      
   Thanks to Your Name for providing an interesting read on marketing success.   
      
   It's nice to know that Fortune and Korn Ferry have yet again ranked Apple   
   as the most admired company in the world. Apple has held the top spot for   
   19 years, based on a survey of about 3,000 executives, directors, and   
   analysts who rate companies on nine criteria including innovation, talent   
   management, and use of capital. Microsoft, Amazon, Nvidia, and Alphabet   
   also placed in the top ten.   
      
   However, my brain is wired for Occams Razor, not marketing hype.   
      
   Apple has a long record of making claims that later turn out to be   
   misleading. Examples include the Batterygate throttling issue, efficiency   
   claims that did not match EU energy ratings, and repeated marketing   
   statements about iOS security that do not line up with findings from CISA   
   and Google Project Zero. Judge Gonzalez has also referred Apple to the   
   Justice Department for concerns about truthfulness in court filings.   
      
   The pattern is that Apple presents its ecosystem restrictions as security   
   measures, but independent researchers have never found measurable security   
   benefit. The restrictions do increase lock-in and profit, so it is   
   reasonable to question whether security is the real motive.   
      
   It is also worth noting that admiration rankings tend to reinforce   
   themselves. Once a company is seen as successful, many people erroneously   
   automatically interpret that marketing success as proof of good judgment   
   rather than looking at the details.   
      
   That feedback loop can create a herd effect where reputation amplifies   
   itself. Some Apple users take pride in being aligned with a highly admired   
   brand mentality, which can make critical discussion harder even when the   
   underlying facts are mixed.   
   --   
   Occam's Razor guides my assessments more than marketing hype ever will.   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)