MSGID: 1:153/716.0 691a6f04
REPLY: 2:5023/24.4222 66823708
CHRS: IBMPC 2
Hi, Gleb!  Recently you wrote in a message to Alexander Koryagin:

[WRT the "Oxford" or "Harvard" comma]:
 AH>> It's a matter of style, not an absolute requirement, and
 AH>> some people recommend using it only when it's needed to
 AH>> avoid confusion:
 AH>> Through the window I saw John, a basketball player and a
 AH>> friend of mine.
 AK>> Are there three of them? ;-)
GH>  Now that I'm reading it I indeed see 3 different persons.

          Exactly my point... I can't be sure because I don't know the author.

          If I were making introductions I might say "I'd like you to meet
John, a basketball player (or a chemistry student or whatever else might
interest you) and a neighbour of ours."  This way you have some idea what the
two of you might have in common.  But if others use punctuation a bit too
sparingly I have little evidence as to whether this person is simply offering
further detail about John.


 AK> If we have a good list (of names, for instance) we would have:
 AK> Through the window I saw John, Peter and Paul, who staggered out
 AK> from the pub.

GH> Does "who" indicate all of them, or just Paul?

          Beats me.  I'd suggest asking Alexander, as you did... [chuckle].


GH> ... End of message, Alexander. Confused? Me too! :-)

          Uh-huh.  So why not bother with an added comma which might help? 
:-))




--- timEd/386 1.10.y2k+
 * Origin: Wits' End, Vancouver CANADA (1:153/716)
SEEN-BY: 1/120 4/0 18/0 80/1 88/0 90/0 1 92/1 104/119 105/81 106/201
SEEN-BY: 116/116 123/0 10 25 126 180 200 755 3001 128/260 129/305
SEEN-BY: 135/115 138/146 153/757 7715 154/10 30 50 700 218/700 840
SEEN-BY: 220/90 221/1 6 360 222/2 226/30 50 227/114 229/110 112 113
SEEN-BY: 229/206 300 317 426 428 470 664 700 240/1120 250/1 261/38
SEEN-BY: 266/512 275/100 1000 282/1038 291/111 301/1 320/219 322/757
SEEN-BY: 335/364 341/66 200 234 342/11 200 396/45 460/58 712/848 1321
SEEN-BY: 880/1 900/0 100 102 106 108 902/0 7 10 19 25 26 27 100 2320/105
SEEN-BY: 3634/0 12 27 56 57 58 5020/400 1042 5075/35
PATH: 153/7715 3634/12 154/10 221/6 341/66 902/26 90/1 229/426