home bbs files messages ]

Forums before death by AOL, social media and spammers... "We can't have nice things"

   linux.debian.bugs.dist      Ohh some weird Debian bug report thing      30,133 messages   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]

   Message 28,642 of 30,133   
   Andrew McMillan to Jonas Smedegaard   
   Bug#1125450: Debian NEW review of rust-s   
   23 Feb 26 12:20:01   
   
   From: andrew@mcmillan.net.nz   
      
   All good points!   
      
   I use both licensecheck and cme (& licenserecon and custom search stuff   
   and ...).  I know cme can be a bit opinionated about some things -   
   perhaps file a bug against it if you disagree with it's output?  It can   
   be a very helpful tool, in spite of it's shortcomings   
      
   Regarding the ITP bug report, it is something I expect to do in due   
   course, but if I made the software perfect I'd not get to the reviews.   
      
   The noreply thing is a bug I introduced today, and only just noticed   
   myself - it's bedtime now, but I'll try and fix it tomorrow.   
      
   The review comments are of course recorded on the review on the   
   dashboard.  I do consider these very minor points that are entirely   
   optional - or indeed things you might well disagree with.  Given your   
   history with Debian, and the numbers of packages you've been involved   
   with, I expect you know considerably more about this stuff than I do.   
      
   And so: perhaps you can help!  Do you think I should just send these   
   messages only to the ITP bug, or CC that along with the maintainers etc   
   that I currently send to?   
      
   We only get the choice, for the accepts (in many cases the accept has   
   no comment), and the notes that we occasionally send - the reject e-   
   mail is sent by the Archive Team, but I could also send an e-mail to   
   the ITP on a reject.   
      
   Thanks,   
   Andrew.   
      
      
   On Mon, 2026-02-23 at 09:08 +0100, Jonas Smedegaard wrote:   
   > Hi Andrew,   
   >    
   > I am taking the liberty of replying the below email via the ITP   
   > bugreport, as I assume sending it to me discretely was unintentional.   
   >    
   > Further comments below quoted block...   
   >    
   > Quoting noreply@dfsg-new-queue.debian.org (2026-02-23 05:31:59)   
   > > The Debian NEW review of rust-scoped-tls-hkt 0.1.5+ds-1 has been   
   > > completed.   
   > >    
   > > Decision: ACCEPTED   
   > > Reviewer: Andrew McMillan   
   > >    
   > > Review comment:   
   > >    
   > > Please change debian/copyright URLs to https.  There also seems to   
   > > be some issue   
   > > `cme dpkg fix` is complaining about having to glue lines together,   
   > > so perhaps   
   > > fix that at the same time.   
   > >    
   > > Thanks!   
   > >    
   > > Full review details:   
   > > https://dfsg-new-queue.debian.org/reviews/rust-scoped-tls-hkt   
   >    
   > Thanks for your review and for the remarks.   
   >    
   > I am unaware of autopkgtest requiring Test-Command on a single line,   
   > and have had no problems making it more readable by breaking it into   
   > more lines, so I will continue to do that, and suggest that you also   
   > consider somehow configuring your use of cme to silence such   
   > warnings.   
   >    
   > Another note related to your use of cme: Please beware that cme does   
   > a   
   > more relaxed scan than licensecheck, in that it suppresses FIXME   
   > notes   
   > produces by licensecheck. See discussion here:   
   > https://bugs.debian.org/950363#20   
   >    
   > A third note: It surprises me that the DFSG team does not make use of   
   > the ITP bugreport when such was opened. Please consider using those   
   > as   
   > your backchannel for remarks like these.   
   >    
   > A fourth note: It is somewhat misleading that you send these notices   
   > using a noreply email address as From: and at the same time add a   
   > Reply-To: address. Some MUAs show From: more prominently than Reply-   
   > To:   
   > which leads to the impression that you want no dialogue, which I   
   > doubt   
   > is intented.   
   >    
   > Kind regards,   
   >    
   >  - Jonas   
      
   --    
   ----------------------------------------------------------------------   
   Porirua, New Zealand                        
    Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â +64 (27) 288 6741   
      
   Â Â Â Â Â Â The truth is rarely pure, and never simple.    
   - Oscar Wilde   
   ----------------------------------------------------------------------   
      
   -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----   
      
   iQIzBAABCAAdFiEEXE+Z7dTLqB92G34ZzmzsFvQ2yQMFAmmcM9YACgkQzmzsFvQ2   
   yQM4Hw/+IbLrmRYJmWjbY0g0USz0+ItUMf1ihM92JMDabCpDzY+002W7cu8v5FBU   
   5JdF/za4g+Lzm/34zpzOO19nY3cuUnKOS8jucZXRsca9Zr4oe1Zs6cGzlou70hul   
   DR1SiXBe5QjaYQ9IBHVloz5aqUikOjI3CIGMS0QVgqrqe1+4psJOh5LtDz8SPRLI   
   gCrcJr9DUkVt5zpMwRxpVUWRka5EKcbYeaba6kwYlSjG3zdff3t6nChPpoxgSdjf   
   6LP72PUNiWbts4b2QkYZRpSKk3xrTRM3AntZMoi8DeFE62sU4/ITpU1EYPje8AiV   
   LSxWs8P/A617OvmZw76tB3s9wjvWbYHD/Wab/DRq8Z/CFvD8s5+ZJiVyLgkQd8Mt   
   CZtdmZR0k4wn2l1AZuTrL89j12qzoG8y45i1+XArYl8cVp2Iu9z1d2401G8zoZUy   
   ogqGplTYS3y3m9HhCjIeTAxzg8XILQH98fqVuChrfY/JPOSPasGP1/TrJq128lAu   
   dVhl5QZmKj6IH9PpzsQmipkt5Y/yqz6wNQxu2ZS6V1OCSie+XxUvJODDei2DL489   
   pwf5368P4Uo6sbX5j/fOmgDN/xFdRAaj5MsjmYJdT2vTFImiUL8qg9lb+f9jSFag   
   4Cw3CQKvoc5Vq58MDOPiybP2j90XO6UlW3zhnJWazZl+LN1VbjU=   
   =gbXM   
   -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)   

[   << oldest   |   < older   |   list   |   newer >   |   newest >>   ]


(c) 1994,  bbs@darkrealms.ca