XPost: uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.drwho, can.arts.sf   
   XPost: rec.arts.tv, rec.arts.sf.tv   
   From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca   
      
   Here’s a review of *Doctor Who: The Impossible Planet*, :   
      
   ---   
      
   *The Impossible Planet* takes the Tenth Doctor   
   and Rose to an abandoned space station orbiting   
   a black hole, where they meet a human crew struggling   
   to survive. They soon discover that a malevolent force,   
   known as the Beast, is manipulating events. This episode   
   marks the first appearance of the Ood, a race of telepathic   
   servants who play a key role in the unfolding mystery.   
      
   The setting is dark and claustrophobic, with the space station   
   situated on a barren, volcanic planet. The imagery of a base on   
   the edge of a black hole immediately creates tension,   
   and the episode's pacing builds on this tension expertly.   
   The story is divided into two parts, and this first half serves   
   as a slow, atmospheric build-up, setting the stage for the dramatic   
   events to come.   
      
   One of the episode's standout features is the tone. The sense   
   of isolation and the looming threat of the black hole adds   
   a layer of existential dread. The crew, stranded with no way   
   to escape, face not only a physical danger but also a metaphysical   
   one. The idea that the planet shouldn’t even exist, defying the laws   
   of physics, adds to the eerie atmosphere. The Doctor's sense of wonder   
   is contrasted with his fear of the unknown, making this an unusually   
   tense adventure for him.   
      
   The human crew members are well-developed, each having a distinct   
   personality and role in the story. Captain Zachary Cross Flane   
   leads with resolve, while Mr. Jefferson is the more hard-nosed   
   security figure. The scientist, Ida Scott, shares the Doctor’s   
   curiosity, and her scenes with him exploring the pit are   
   particularly compelling. Toby Zed, an archaeologist possessed   
   by the Beast, provides some of the episode’s creepiest moments.   
   His transformation from mild-mannered scientist to a vessel   
   for pure evil is unsettling, and his possession scenes are haunting.   
      
   The Ood, telepathic aliens who serve as the crew’s labor force,   
   introduce a tragic element to the story. Their natural telepathy   
   is hijacked by the Beast, turning them into dangerous foes.   
   The Doctor and Rose’s empathy towards the Ood is contrasted   
   with the crew's treatment of them as mere tools, raising   
   questions about exploitation and the morality of servitude.   
   The Ood’s role as both victim and villain complicates   
   the ethical framework of the story, making them one of the more   
   memorable alien species in the series.   
      
   The Beast, though largely unseen in this episode, casts a long   
   shadow over the story. The idea that it may be the source of all   
   religious concepts of evil taps into deep-seated fears   
   about the unknown and unknowable. The Doctor's reluctance to believe   
   in the existence of such an entity adds a layer of skepticism,   
   while Rose's open-mindedness reflects her more emotional approach   
   to the mystery. This tension between faith and science runs throughout   
   the episode, making the Beast a particularly menacing villain despite   
   its limited screen time in this part.   
      
   Rose’s character development is another highlight of the episode.   
   Her growing confidence and partnership with the Doctor are evident   
   as she takes charge in difficult situations. Her interactions with   
   the crew, particularly her attempts to boost morale and provide comfort,   
   show her maturity. However, the episode also foreshadows the eventual   
   separation of Rose and the Doctor, as their relationship seems   
   to be deepening in ways that suggest future heartbreak.   
      
   The direction and production design are superb, contributing   
   to the overall sense of doom and isolation. The space station's   
   industrial, grimy look adds to the sense of realism, while   
   the volcanic planet below feels like a truly hostile environment.   
   The black hole looming in the background serves as a constant   
   reminder of the crew’s precarious situation. The episode’s   
   special effects, particularly the black hole and the Ood,   
   are impressive for their time, adding to the overall immersive experience.   
      
   The pacing of *The Impossible Planet* is slower than some   
   other *Doctor Who* episodes, but this works in its favour.   
   The gradual build-up of tension allows for deeper character exploration   
   and more meaningful interactions between the Doctor, Rose, and the crew.   
   The mystery of the planet and the Beast is intriguing,   
   and the episode leaves just enough unanswered questions to keep   
   the audience hooked for the second part.   
      
   While *The Impossible Planet* doesn’t resolve the central mystery   
   in this episode, it sets up an intriguing and suspenseful story   
   that balances action, horror, and philosophical questions   
   about the nature of evil and the unknown. The tension between   
   the Doctor’s scientific curiosity and the existential dread   
   posed by the Beast makes for a compelling conflict,   
   one that resonates on both an intellectual and emotional level.   
      
   In conclusion, *The Impossible Planet* is a standout episode   
   of the second series of *Doctor Who*. Its blend of atmospheric   
   horror, strong character development, and philosophical themes   
   make it a memorable and engaging story. The Ood and the Beast   
   are iconic additions to the *Doctor Who* universe, and   
   the episode’s pacing and tone create a sense of looming danger   
   that builds to an unforgettable climax.   
      
   ---   
      
   Rating: 9/10   
      
   This episode effectively combines suspense, horror,   
   and deep existential questions, while also providing emotional   
   moments and character development for both the Doctor and Rose.   
   Its atmosphere and pacing are among the best in the series,   
   making it a near-perfect *Doctor Who* adventure.   
   --   
   Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca   
   Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising!   
   Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)