From: daniel47@nomail.afraid.org   
      
   On 28/11/2025 1:26 am, The True Doctor wrote:   
   > On 26/11/2025 10:31, Dumas Walker wrote:   
   >>>>> Or do you seriously think the Earth's moon hatched into a   
   >>>>> giant space dragon which flew away with 90% of it's mass and   
   >>>>>  then the moon somehow reformed into the exact shape it had   
   >>>>> before with exactly the same mass,   
   >>   
   >>>> In another Dimension .... YES.   
   >>   
   >>> Wrong! Where did the missing mass come from? Are you also   
   >>> claiming that the moon landings were all faked?   
   >>   
   >> I think he is claiming that the Moon landings, etc., all happened   
   >> in this dimension, while the events of Kill the Moon happened in   
   >> one where Moon landings, etc., may or may not have happened.   
   >   
   > It's already been established in Matt Smith's second season and the   
   > SJAs that the moon landings did happen and that Liz Shaw was   
   > stationed on a UNIT base on the moon.   
      
   I'll tell you what, Aggy, here in MY Universe the moon landings DID   
   happen .... so that's got part of your DREAMS fixed!!   
      
   >> The end result being that the mirrors,   
      
   Yes!!   
      
   > golf balls,   
      
   Yes!!   
      
   > Liz Shaw,   
      
   NO!! Not in my Universe, anyway!!   
      
   >> etc., would still be on the Moon in our dimension (because it isn't   
   >> an egg in this one), while in the "Egg dimension" Liz may never   
   >> have been on the Moon and those other objects might/might not have   
   >> ever been.   
   >   
   > That would contradict everything we know from Matt Smith.   
      
   Wacko!!   
      
   >>>> In another Dimension .... YES.   
   >>   
   >>> Wrong! No such dimension exists otherwise all history would be   
   >>> unrecognisable after 1969.   
      
   Bullshit!   
      
   >> In this dimension, history would have continued as it did.   
   >>   
   >> Far fetched, yes, but it is really the only way you can make it   
   >> work... if you want it to work.   
   >   
   > Nonsense. All the rock formations, craters, seas, and markings on the   
   > moon are exactly the same before the moon hatches into a giant space   
   > dragon which flies away with 90% of the moon's mass and after the   
   > moon reforms looking exactly the same as it did before and with all   
   > of the missing mass coming back out of nowhere. On top of that   
   > everyone on the space shuttle is slammed to the ground during free   
   > fall as if their weight had massively increased instead of being   
   > completely weightless. This entire story defies all belief and   
   > therefore nothing from that point onwards can be considered to be   
   > canon.   
   >>   
   >> Even more far fetched when you consider that the Great Time War   
   >> sealed the "walls" of this dimension making travel into another one   
   >> very difficult.   
   --   
   Daniel70   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)