From: daniel47@nomail.afraid.org   
      
   On 2/12/2025 3:34 am, The True Doctor wrote:   
   > On 29/11/2025 17:47, Dumas Walker wrote:   
   >>>> I think he is claiming that the Moon landings, etc., all   
   >>>> happened in this dimension, while the events of Kill the Moon   
   >>>> happened in one where Moon landings, etc., may or may not have   
   >>>> happened.   
   >>   
   >>> It's already been established in Matt Smith's second season and   
   >>> the SJAs that the moon landings did happen and that Liz Shaw was   
   >>> stationed on a UNIT base on the moon.   
   >>   
   >> Correct, but was it established anywhere that the *episode in   
   >> question* 100% happened in the same dimension as the moon   
   >> landings, Liz Shaw being stationed on the Moon, etc.?   
   >   
   > Unless it was said otherwise then it occurs in the same dimension as   
   > The Impossible Astronaut and the SJAs which follow it.   
   >   
   >> As I said before, it is....   
   >>   
   >>>> Even more far fetched when you consider that the Great Time War   
   >>>> sealed the "walls" of this dimension making travel into another   
   >>>> one very difficult.   
   >>   
   >> So I do not believe it is likely that the events of Kill the Moon   
   >> happened in a different dimension, universe, or timeline but it is   
   >> the only way to explain the events of that episode without   
   >> dismissing it as non-canonical -- the latter which I am inclined   
   >> to do.   
   >   
   > There is no way to explain the total and absolute bullshit that   
   > happened in Kill the Moon because it defies all the most basic and   
   > fundamental laws of physics. Therefore it cannot be canon, nor   
   > anything that comes after it.   
   >   
   Yet a 'guy' that flys around to different Times and Places in a Police   
   Box CAN be Canon even though it "defies all the most basic and   
   fundamental laws of physics"!! Really??   
      
   You tend to 'pick and choose' what YOU (and the fundamental laws of   
   physics) will allow, don't you, Aggy??   
   --   
   Daniel70   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)