XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.sf.tv   
   XPost: can.arts.sf   
   From: doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca   
      
   AI/LLM reviews Star Trek: Voyager — “Rise”   
      
   Google Gemini   
      
   Rating: 4/10   
   The Plot and Structural Flaws   
      
   "Rise" is an episode that struggles with its identity, attempting to be a   
   "disaster movie" in space while dealing with a friction-filled character study   
   between Neelix and Tuvok. The crew of Voyager is attempting to help the Nezu,   
   a race whose planet is    
   being bombarded by asteroids. When Tuvok and Neelix’s shuttle (inevitably)   
   crashes, they find themselves stranded on the surface with a small group of   
   survivors, including a scientist named Dr. Vatm and a traitor named Sklar.   
      
   The core conceit involves an "orbital tether"—a space elevator—which the   
   group must use to reach the upper atmosphere to contact Voyager. The journey   
   is plagued by mechanical failures, poisoning, and interpersonal bickering. Dr.   
   Vatm is murdered, and    
   it is eventually revealed that the asteroids are actually artificial weapons   
   used by the Etanian Order to force an evacuation so they can seize the planet.   
   Critical Analysis: High Concept, Low Execution   
      
   "Rise" earns a 4/10 because it suffers from many of the tropes that plagued   
   Voyager’s middle seasons. The "shuttle crash of the week" had already become   
   a cliché by this point, and the Etanian Order are generic "villains of the   
   week" with little depth.   
      
   The episode’s primary saving grace is the confrontation between Neelix and   
   Tuvok. For years, Tuvok’s disdain for Neelix was played for laughs; here,   
   Neelix finally calls out Tuvok’s condescension. Ethan Phillips delivers a   
   strong performance,    
   showing a side of Neelix that is competent, frustrated, and deeply observant.   
   He forces Tuvok to acknowledge that "logic" can sometimes be a shield for   
   simple rudeness.   
      
   However, the surrounding plot is messy. The "whodunit" mystery regarding Dr.   
   Vatm’s death feels rushed and lacks suspense. The physics of the space   
   elevator are handled with "technobabble" that even by Star Trek standards   
   feels thin, and the ending—   
   where a single data pad found on the roof of the elevator magically provides   
   the exact shield frequencies needed to defeat the enemy fleet—is a deus ex   
   machina of the highest order.   
      
   While the visual of the space elevator is ambitious and the Tuvok/Neelix   
   dynamic receives some much-needed development, "Rise" ultimately feels like a   
   "filler" episode. It lacks the emotional stakes and long-term consequences   
   that made its contemporary, "   
   Doctor Bashir, I Presume," a landmark in the franchise.   
   Comparison Summary   
      
       "Doctor Bashir, I Presume" is essential viewing. It changes the trajectory   
   of a main character, explores deep ethical questions about the Federation’s   
   soul, and features top-tier acting. It is a 9/10 because it respects the   
   audience’s    
   intelligence and the show’s history.   
      
       "Rise" is a 4/10 "popcorn" episode. It is entertaining enough for a casual   
   watch but is marred by "reset button" plotting and a lack of narrative weight.   
   Its only lasting contribution is the incremental growth in the Odd Couple   
   relationship between    
   the ship’s cook and its tactical officer.   
      
   ChatGPT   
      
   Plot Summary (Detailed)   
      
   “Rise” is the 19th episode of Star Trek: Voyager Season 3. It’s an   
   episode built around survival, teamwork, trust, and the exploration of   
   cultural and interpersonal clashes. The story begins with USS Voyager coming   
   to the aid of a world — home to    
   the Nezu species — which is repeatedly bombarded by deadly asteroids. The   
   Voyager crew determines that simply vaporizing the asteroids isn’t feasible.   
      
   Tuvok and Neelix are selected to accompany a shuttlecraft mission aimed at   
   investigating and stopping the source of the bombardment. Shortly after   
   entering the planet’s atmosphere, turbulence causes the shuttle to crash.   
   Tuvok, Neelix, and several    
   members of the Nezu populace, including the scientist Dr. Vatm and miner   
   Hanjuan, survive the crash but are now stranded on the hostile surface.   
   Communication with Voyager is lost, forcing them to consider alternative ways   
   to signal for rescue.   
      
   In the distance they spot a maglev space elevator — a towering structure   
   extending from the planet’s surface into orbit. Neelix suggests that if they   
   can repair and ascend the elevator, they can reach high enough altitude to   
   restore contact with    
   Voyager or at least be detected. Though Tuvok’s logical demeanor frequently   
   clashes with Neelix’s more emotional and optimistic approach, the group   
   bands together to fix the elevator circuitry and start the ascent.   
      
   Along the ascent, tensions rise — both literally and figuratively. They face   
   dangerous mechanical failures, diminishing oxygen levels, and interpersonal   
   conflicts. At one critical juncture, Dr. Vatm’s water supply is poisoned,   
   leading to his death.    
   With his dying words he hints that something is hidden on the elevator’s   
   roof. While initially skeptical, Tuvok eventually investigates and finds a   
   data storage device containing tactical information on an alien vessel —   
   intelligence that becomes    
   critical later.   
      
   However, this discovery coincides with increased distrust and confusion. One   
   of the party — Sklar — turns violent, pushing Tuvok off the roof (though   
   it’s unclear if he dies) and then attacking Neelix. This raises questions of   
   motive, loyalty, and    
   survival ethics. Eventually, Neelix, nearly unconscious but driven by   
   determination, manages to open the elevator door after seeing Tuvok through   
   the window, signaling that unity — not division — is essential to survival.   
      
   Back aboard Voyager, the crew’s investigation reveals that the asteroid   
   bombardments aren’t natural at all: they’re being manipulated by an   
   outside faction known as the Etanian Order, who are using the planetary   
   catastrophe to drive the indigenous    
   population off their world for colonial purposes. By using the tactical data   
   found on the elevator, Voyager successfully forces the Etanians to retreat,   
   securing the planet’s safety.   
      
   Thematic Analysis   
      
   At its heart, “Rise” blends classic sci-fi adventure with interpersonal   
   dynamics — particularly the flawed yet compelling relationship between Tuvok   
   and Neelix.   
      
   Tuvok vs. Neelix: Logic and Emotion   
      
   The episode places two diametrically opposed personalities into an intense   
   survival scenario. Tuvok’s Vulcan logic often clashes with Neelix’s   
   Talaxian enthusiasm and emotional reasoning. While this juxtaposition might   
   seem cliché, the elevated    
   stakes — cramped quarters of an elevator, suffocating air, and impending   
   rescue or doom — amplify every disagreement.   
      
      
   [continued in next message]   
      
   --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05   
    * Origin: you cannot sedate... all the things you hate (1:229/2)